Why do some collarbone breaks heal quickly while others are far more serious?

Jonathan P. Braman, M.D - TRIA Orthopaedic Center

Broken collarbones, or “clavicles” are a frequent result of falls, especially involving cycling. Most breaks can be managed without needing surgery, by placing the arm in a sling for a period of time then gradually getting the strength and motion back over time.

Sometimes, however, they do not heal in a sling. This can be especially troubling for cyclists as the collarbone absorbs much of the stress during long rides.

One reason why some breaks don’t heal is if during the first part of healing, too much motion occurs. This can cause the broken bone to fail to grow back together.

Also, new studies looking at how people do after breaking their collarbones has shown that some broken collarbones should be operated on at the start. As a result, it is best to see a shoulder surgeon with any broken collarbone.